Into the Arms of
Strangers
Stories of the Kindertransport
review by Elias Savada, 29 September 2000
Holocaust
related documentaries have polled well with Oscar voters over the
last five years, winning three times. Poignantly reflecting on one
of mankind’s darker moments, the Academy has deservedly recognized
the important heroics of the subjects and the filmmakers for The
Last Days, Anne Frank
Remembered, and The Long
Way Home. The latter, an extraordinary tale of concentration
camp survivors who endured additional physical hardships in WWII’s
aftermath, was directed by Mark Jonathan Harris. His latest effort, Into
the Arms of Strangers, inspired by producer Deborah
Oppenheimer’s journey of discovery about her late mother’s past
and produced in cooperation with the United States Holocaust
Memorial Museum, appears legitimately destined for award
consideration. Spearheaded with an unusual early push by Warner
Bros. (many documentaries only get attention after
they win a golden statuette, and then merely via cable/educational
television networks or limited home video release), the two-hour
feature just opened on single screens in five major markets (New
York, Los Angeles, Washington, Boston, and Toronto). The
well-crafted film highlights the Kindertransport, an unprecedented humanitarian rescue effort that
ultimately saved 10,000 children, mostly Jews, from certain death.
On a historic scale, the number pales to the 1,500,000 children who
perished in the Holocaust, yet for those under-17-year-olds
dramatically wrenched from their German, Austrian, and Czech parents
and guardians, life, no matter how uncertain in a land of
English-speaking strangers, was better than none at all.
Sparsely
narrated by Dame Judi Dench, the filmmakers have 12 witnesses
recount their horrifying, yet startlingly fresh, childhood stories
of 60 years ago. These Kinder
survived and flourished despite being torn from their families in
the nine months before the onslaught of World War II. A pair of
rescuers and two parents are also called upon to provide their
perspective. Their distressing stories of separation anxiety unfold
before a stationary camera and a soft-focus blue backdrop, unlocking
deep-rooted experiences that brings their past to life and transfix
the viewer. The still and moving archival images that overlay the
soundtrack (expertly designed by seven-time Academy Award winner
Gary Rydstrom) effectively supplement their heart-rending tales.
Despite the growing library of such films, locating unique, fresh,
newsreel, home movie, and photographic material (kudos to researcher
Corrinne Collett) did showcase some disturbing representations of
the era, particularly a brief glimpse of an intoxicating carousel, a
bouquet of helium-filled black balloons emblazoned with the Nazi
swastika, and shattering images of a German synagogue being burned.
There are several ghostly recreations (all using only authentic Kindertransport artifacts) evoking the horror of Kristallnacht,
"the night of broken glass," a nationwide series of attacks
orchestrated by Josef Goebbels, Hitler’s propaganda minister, on
November 9, 1938 that set a thousand synagogues ablaze, destroyed
more than 7,500 Jewish businesses, and kidnapped tens of thousands
of male Jews to ransom back, dead or alive, to their families. This
turning point in the fate of Germany’s Jews prodded Britain’s
Parliament to temporarily accept refugee children and thus began the
Kindertransport.
The
ten thousand beneficiaries were previously profiled in Melissa
Hacker’s My Knees Were
Jumping: Remembering the Kindertransport. Like Into
the Arms of Strangers, that film also was springboarded by the
daughter of a Kind émigré
(costume designer Ruth Morley), with some of the same survivors
re-telling their stories: Vienna-born Kurt Fuchel, one of the
handful of children eventually reunited with his parents after the
war; novelist Lore Segal, whose determination as a ten-year-old
adrift in England managed to secure the necessary domestic service
visa for her parents and a birthday reunion on safe ground (her
95-year-old mother Franzi
Groszmann is also interviewed); and now-deceased rescuer Norbert
Wollheim, 25 years old when he began organizing the Berlin end of
the rescue program that saved between six and seven thousand
children.
As
the children are collected and shipped east, their farewells are
tearfully recreated, their harrowing journey painstakingly
recreated. The actual train route from Berlin to Holland is
re-filmed as several survivors recall the trepidation and sadness
permeating their excursion, the muted clatter of the metal wheels an
ominous heartbeat. It is only after safely being delivered to Dutch
authorities that there are any images of the children smiling in the
entire undertaking, savoring hot cocoa and sweet Zwieback biscuits
as if they were manna from heaven.
Another
witness, Lory Cahn, recalls her father’s tear-filled farewell only
to have him, unable to part with his daughter, pluck her from the
train window as it was departing the station. She survived
Theresienstadt, Auschwitz, and six other death camps; her parents
did not. When liberated at Bergen-Belsen she weighed 58 pounds.
All of the interviewees should be
recognized for their touching memories -- some painful, others less
so -- and their uplifting courage in a Hellish world unfit for any
child; all were truly innocents cast into the arms of strangers, all
hoping they would some day be reunited with their families. It
is a compelling film, sharply focused in story and content.
Cameraman Don Lenzer and editor Kate Amend zoom and pan to the
important faces, generally children, found in the archival
materials, concentrating your attention where it should be. The film
zig-zags between its subjects as their stories unfold, connected by
shared experiences and overlaid with history lessons that expand the
subject beyond its intimacy. Such is the case of Alexander Gordon, a
Hamburg orphan who was one of the first to leave Germany, yet was
later arrested as an enemy alien in England in mid-1940 and expelled
to Australia aboard the HMT
Dunera. Then just 18 years old, he remembers being subjected to
two months of near starvation at sea, scraping bits of jam from an
empty pot. On a ship filled to twice its capacity, barely escaping
destruction by a German U-boat, he survived the journey, believing a
simple box of food (cheese sandwiches, apples, and bananas) he
received as the boat docked down under to be the best meal he ever
had. Newsreels, stills, headlines, and other documentary techniques
efficiently flesh out the sequence.
The
faded hopes of repatriation closed the door on one of history’s
most painful chapters. Those left to fend for themselves did as best
they could. Alexander Gordon insists, on the verge of tears, that "I
was meant to survive to bring on another generation." Nicholas
Winton, the London organizer for the Kindertransport,
believed most of the children were happy. "Everyone was at least
alive at the end of the war." Deborah Oppenheimer and Mark Jonathan
Harris have a much larger family to be proud of with Into
the Arms of Strangers.
Click here to read Elias Savada's interview.
|
|