Bruno
review by Gregory Avery, 1 December 2000
Walking down the passageways of
a Catholic grade school on Long Island, the majestic Angela (Stacey
Halprin) leads young Bruno (Alex D. Linz) by the hand while his
classmates at school, who seem alarmingly lax in discipline, take
the opportunity to throw the usual juvenile epithets, mostly
regarding Angela's size. Angela, in the way she moves, looks like
someone you would not want to mess around with
-- her stride is determined and steady, as if powers great
and small might reside in her, waiting to jump out. But one of the
kids' crude remarks gets to her, and for an instant she just can't
help herself: she stops and looks back, with the expression of
someone who would like to get a break for once and can't. Then she
quickly pulls herself together. "Ignore
them,"
she tells Bruno, and they get into Angela's huge yellow car, with
license plates that read "DIVA,"
and drive off, but not before Angela gives in just a little bit to
her emotions, and pulls the car around just far enough up on the
curve to throw a real good scare into the little kids with their
little, stinging remarks.
The sight of Angela melting, in
spite of herself, under the kinds of circumstances many of us
had thought, or hoped, were left behind in school is one of
the most affecting things about Bruno -- which marks Shirley
MacLaine's debut as a feature film director (and which is getting
its U.S. debut on the Starz channel this month) -- and Stacey
Halprin's performance is remarkable not just for the way she allows
herself to be shown as a "large
woman"
in the film, but also for other points such as the way she expresses
herself, how her character reacts to the way people treat her and
how she compensates for it. She shows great paternal love towards
Bruno, a kid who's just a little bit smaller than the other boys at
school and, because of that plus the fact that he can't defend
himself, gets piled on a lot. Bruno is bright, but not especially
aggressive. Angela, on the other hand, seems sparring for a fight
with the woman (Joey Lauren Adams) whom Angela's husband (Gary
Sinise) left her for. Adams, stuck in a one-dimensional b-queen
role, doesn't seem like much of an attraction; Sinise, on the other
hand, who seems draped in melancholy in the picture, doesn't seem
like much of a loss. But Angela's need to have him back in her life,
even if the two of them aren't particularly suited for each other,
is palpable and movingly depicted.
Part of Bruno is about how
people habitually find ways to pick on other people for no good
reason (or all the wrong reasons). The picture is also about how the
title character wants to wear a dress. It has something to do with a
dream he has, with quite possibly some Divine inspiration mixed in.
With his upbringing in the Catholic faith, he sees the outfit not as
women's clothing but as "holy
rainments,"
and he argues this point vociferously. "The
Pope wears a dress!"
he tells the Mother Superior (Kathy Bates) in charge of his school,
and who has a framed photo of John Paul II on her desk. Nonetheless,
it drives everyone bananas, except for Angela, who not only
accommodates Bruno but is an expert seamstress, and Bruno's new
friend Shaniqua (Kiami Davael), a young girl who always comes to
class wearing her school uniform, a bright red cowboy hat, and
holsters with two toy pistols (and who may also be having some
troubles at home which are only murkily alluded to). When one of the
boys makes a crack about Shaniqua's skin color, Bruno clobbers him.
Bruno, Angela and Shaniqua are all
outsiders, and the point of the movie is that people should be
allowed to express who they really are in any way they wish. Except
for his dream, Bruno's apparel decision doesn't seem to have
anything to do with his identity one way of the other, except for
the fact that he simply wants to do this. However, he has been
spending lots of time studying the dictionary so that he can compete
in a series of Catholic school spelling bees that culminate in a
national contest and an opportunity for the winner to have an
audience with the Pope. Bruno participates in the event wearing a
dress. Does it cross anybody's mind in the film that he may want to
make an exception on what he wears just for the competition, so that
all his hard work won't be for nothing? No. Bruno wearing a dress
and competing in the spelling bee are meant to be concurrent
victories.
Unfortunately, Stacey Halprin's
character is sidelined at the movie's halfway point, and MacLaine
herself barrels right in as Bruno's grandmother, who wears men's
style trousers, shirts, and outer coats, and dares anyone to say
anything about them. She supports him and teaches him how to put up
his dukes, so there's little doubt as to how things are going to
turn out. Bruno shows up at the national spelling finals wearing a
Western outfit and wig that makes him look like a combination of
Dolly Parton and Dale Evans (and, I am afraid to say, Jonbenet
Ramsey, a distinction which I hope was unintentional).
MacLaine shows an aptitude for
directing and working with actors: Alex D. Linz gives a winning,
smart, chin-up portrayal of Bruno, and Kathy Bates is a hoot during
scenes such as the one where, in private, she wearily genuflects,
saying "Oh,
popi, popi...."
to her photo of the Pope, before turning it face-down before
producing a cigar and lighting it up. But the film belays its most
interesting aspects in favor of ones that are more pleasing, easier,
and reassuring, even if they end up seeming forced. We know who all
the bad guys are, which characters we are supposed to root for, and
what sort of message we're supposed to come away with from all this.
In other words, the film turns out to be not nearly as brave,
fearless, and daring as Bruno himself is.
|
Directed by:
Shirley MacLaine
Starring:
Alex D. Linz
Stacey Halprin
Gary Sinise
Joey Lauren Adams
Jennifer Tilly
Kiami Davael
Shirley MacLaine
Kathy Bates
Written
by:
David Ciminello
FULL
CREDITS
BUY
VIDEO
SHOWTIMES
|
|